A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations

Murray Crease, Jo Lumsden, Bob Longworth

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Increasingly, lab evaluations of mobile applications are incorporating mobility. The inclusion of mobility alone, however, is insufficient to generate a realistic evaluation context since real-life users will typically be required to monitor their environment while moving through it.
While field evaluations represent a more realistic evaluation context, such evaluations pose difficulties, including data capture and environmental control, which mean that a lab-based evaluation is often a more practical choice. This paper describes a novel evaluation technique that mimics a realistic mobile usage context in a lab setting.
The technique requires that participants monitor their environment and change the route they are walking to avoid dynamically changing hazards (much as reallife users would be required to do). Two studies that employed this technique are described, and the results (which indicate the technique is useful) are discussed.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationPeople and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it
Subtitle of host publicationproceedings of HCI 2007 : the 21st British HCI Group annual conference
EditorsLinden J. Ball, M. Angela Sasse, Corina Sas, Thomas C. Ormerod, Alan Dix, Peter Bagnall, Tom McEwan
PublisherBritish Computer Society
Pages99-108
Number of pages10
Volume1
ISBN (Print)978-1-902505-94-7, 978-1-902505-95-4
Publication statusPublished - 2007
Event21st British HCI Group annual conference - University of Lancaster, Lancaster, United Kingdom
Duration: 3 Sep 20077 Sep 2007

Conference

Conference21st British HCI Group annual conference
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityLancaster
Period3/09/077/09/07

Fingerprint

Data acquisition
Hazards

Cite this

Crease, M., Lumsden, J., & Longworth, B. (2007). A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations. In L. J. Ball, M. A. Sasse, C. Sas, T. C. Ormerod, A. Dix, P. Bagnall, & T. McEwan (Eds.), People and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it: proceedings of HCI 2007 : the 21st British HCI Group annual conference (Vol. 1, pp. 99-108). British Computer Society .
Crease, Murray ; Lumsden, Jo ; Longworth, Bob. / A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations. People and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it: proceedings of HCI 2007 : the 21st British HCI Group annual conference. editor / Linden J. Ball ; M. Angela Sasse ; Corina Sas ; Thomas C. Ormerod ; Alan Dix ; Peter Bagnall ; Tom McEwan. Vol. 1 British Computer Society , 2007. pp. 99-108
@inproceedings{3f96d655ddbe4efc8ec01d00cc96b10e,
title = "A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations",
abstract = "Increasingly, lab evaluations of mobile applications are incorporating mobility. The inclusion of mobility alone, however, is insufficient to generate a realistic evaluation context since real-life users will typically be required to monitor their environment while moving through it.While field evaluations represent a more realistic evaluation context, such evaluations pose difficulties, including data capture and environmental control, which mean that a lab-based evaluation is often a more practical choice. This paper describes a novel evaluation technique that mimics a realistic mobile usage context in a lab setting.The technique requires that participants monitor their environment and change the route they are walking to avoid dynamically changing hazards (much as reallife users would be required to do). Two studies that employed this technique are described, and the results (which indicate the technique is useful) are discussed.",
author = "Murray Crease and Jo Lumsden and Bob Longworth",
year = "2007",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-1-902505-94-7",
volume = "1",
pages = "99--108",
editor = "Ball, {Linden J.} and Sasse, {M. Angela} and Corina Sas and Ormerod, {Thomas C.} and Alan Dix and Peter Bagnall and Tom McEwan",
booktitle = "People and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it",
publisher = "British Computer Society",

}

Crease, M, Lumsden, J & Longworth, B 2007, A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations. in LJ Ball, MA Sasse, C Sas, TC Ormerod, A Dix, P Bagnall & T McEwan (eds), People and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it: proceedings of HCI 2007 : the 21st British HCI Group annual conference. vol. 1, British Computer Society , pp. 99-108, 21st British HCI Group annual conference, Lancaster, United Kingdom, 3/09/07.

A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations. / Crease, Murray; Lumsden, Jo; Longworth, Bob.

People and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it: proceedings of HCI 2007 : the 21st British HCI Group annual conference. ed. / Linden J. Ball; M. Angela Sasse; Corina Sas; Thomas C. Ormerod; Alan Dix; Peter Bagnall; Tom McEwan. Vol. 1 British Computer Society , 2007. p. 99-108.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations

AU - Crease, Murray

AU - Lumsden, Jo

AU - Longworth, Bob

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - Increasingly, lab evaluations of mobile applications are incorporating mobility. The inclusion of mobility alone, however, is insufficient to generate a realistic evaluation context since real-life users will typically be required to monitor their environment while moving through it.While field evaluations represent a more realistic evaluation context, such evaluations pose difficulties, including data capture and environmental control, which mean that a lab-based evaluation is often a more practical choice. This paper describes a novel evaluation technique that mimics a realistic mobile usage context in a lab setting.The technique requires that participants monitor their environment and change the route they are walking to avoid dynamically changing hazards (much as reallife users would be required to do). Two studies that employed this technique are described, and the results (which indicate the technique is useful) are discussed.

AB - Increasingly, lab evaluations of mobile applications are incorporating mobility. The inclusion of mobility alone, however, is insufficient to generate a realistic evaluation context since real-life users will typically be required to monitor their environment while moving through it.While field evaluations represent a more realistic evaluation context, such evaluations pose difficulties, including data capture and environmental control, which mean that a lab-based evaluation is often a more practical choice. This paper describes a novel evaluation technique that mimics a realistic mobile usage context in a lab setting.The technique requires that participants monitor their environment and change the route they are walking to avoid dynamically changing hazards (much as reallife users would be required to do). Two studies that employed this technique are described, and the results (which indicate the technique is useful) are discussed.

UR - http://ewic.bcs.org/content/ConWebDoc/13296

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 978-1-902505-94-7

SN - 978-1-902505-95-4

VL - 1

SP - 99

EP - 108

BT - People and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it

A2 - Ball, Linden J.

A2 - Sasse, M. Angela

A2 - Sas, Corina

A2 - Ormerod, Thomas C.

A2 - Dix, Alan

A2 - Bagnall, Peter

A2 - McEwan, Tom

PB - British Computer Society

ER -

Crease M, Lumsden J, Longworth B. A technique for incorporating dynamic paths in lab-based mobile evaluations. In Ball LJ, Sasse MA, Sas C, Ormerod TC, Dix A, Bagnall P, McEwan T, editors, People and computers XXI HCI...but not as we know it: proceedings of HCI 2007 : the 21st British HCI Group annual conference. Vol. 1. British Computer Society . 2007. p. 99-108