Developing intrinsically motivated information systems - a critical systems approach

Petros Panagiotidis, John S. Edwards*

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper deals with the problematic of development methodologies for organisational information systems and especially with their application to business systems. Historically, information systems development methodologies tend to fail, because either they take the organisational purposefulness for granted, or they do not analyse it thoroughly. This paper's position is that the analysis, and the definition or redefinition of the systemic purpose are regarded as the utmost expression of the system 's purposefulness. This is to be achieved by ensuring the participation of all the stakeholders who affect, or are affected by, a particular business system's operations. The nature of participation, defined as a process of the stakeholders' perceptual exchanges, is deemed to be problematic in itself, due to the influence exerted upon it by organisational power, coercion and false consciousness. The paper highlights the philosophical reasons for the failures of information systems development methodologies, and provides a conceptual solution to this problematic as well as a strategy for the development of intrinsically motivated organisational information systems. The intrinsically motivated information systems methodology outlined here (BSPA) is intended to yield organisational information systems that demonstrably improve co-ordination of organisational activities, by enabling the development and maintenance of a single/multifaceted view of purpose throughout organisations.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)211-226
Number of pages16
JournalInformation Systems Frontiers
Volume3
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2001

Fingerprint

Information Systems
Information systems
Methodology
System Development
Industry
Maintenance
Tend
Business
Participation

Bibliographical note

The original publication is available at www.springerlink.com

Keywords

  • business systems
  • coercion
  • complementarism
  • false consciousness
  • methodology
  • power

Cite this

@article{5585aa538cfd410da13ae0e320fe623d,
title = "Developing intrinsically motivated information systems - a critical systems approach",
abstract = "This paper deals with the problematic of development methodologies for organisational information systems and especially with their application to business systems. Historically, information systems development methodologies tend to fail, because either they take the organisational purposefulness for granted, or they do not analyse it thoroughly. This paper's position is that the analysis, and the definition or redefinition of the systemic purpose are regarded as the utmost expression of the system 's purposefulness. This is to be achieved by ensuring the participation of all the stakeholders who affect, or are affected by, a particular business system's operations. The nature of participation, defined as a process of the stakeholders' perceptual exchanges, is deemed to be problematic in itself, due to the influence exerted upon it by organisational power, coercion and false consciousness. The paper highlights the philosophical reasons for the failures of information systems development methodologies, and provides a conceptual solution to this problematic as well as a strategy for the development of intrinsically motivated organisational information systems. The intrinsically motivated information systems methodology outlined here (BSPA) is intended to yield organisational information systems that demonstrably improve co-ordination of organisational activities, by enabling the development and maintenance of a single/multifaceted view of purpose throughout organisations.",
keywords = "business systems, coercion, complementarism, false consciousness, methodology, power",
author = "Petros Panagiotidis and Edwards, {John S.}",
note = "The original publication is available at www.springerlink.com",
year = "2001",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1023/A:1011400409028",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "211--226",
journal = "Information Systems Frontiers",
issn = "1387-3326",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "2",

}

Developing intrinsically motivated information systems - a critical systems approach. / Panagiotidis, Petros; Edwards, John S.

In: Information Systems Frontiers, Vol. 3, No. 2, 12.2001, p. 211-226.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Developing intrinsically motivated information systems - a critical systems approach

AU - Panagiotidis, Petros

AU - Edwards, John S.

N1 - The original publication is available at www.springerlink.com

PY - 2001/12

Y1 - 2001/12

N2 - This paper deals with the problematic of development methodologies for organisational information systems and especially with their application to business systems. Historically, information systems development methodologies tend to fail, because either they take the organisational purposefulness for granted, or they do not analyse it thoroughly. This paper's position is that the analysis, and the definition or redefinition of the systemic purpose are regarded as the utmost expression of the system 's purposefulness. This is to be achieved by ensuring the participation of all the stakeholders who affect, or are affected by, a particular business system's operations. The nature of participation, defined as a process of the stakeholders' perceptual exchanges, is deemed to be problematic in itself, due to the influence exerted upon it by organisational power, coercion and false consciousness. The paper highlights the philosophical reasons for the failures of information systems development methodologies, and provides a conceptual solution to this problematic as well as a strategy for the development of intrinsically motivated organisational information systems. The intrinsically motivated information systems methodology outlined here (BSPA) is intended to yield organisational information systems that demonstrably improve co-ordination of organisational activities, by enabling the development and maintenance of a single/multifaceted view of purpose throughout organisations.

AB - This paper deals with the problematic of development methodologies for organisational information systems and especially with their application to business systems. Historically, information systems development methodologies tend to fail, because either they take the organisational purposefulness for granted, or they do not analyse it thoroughly. This paper's position is that the analysis, and the definition or redefinition of the systemic purpose are regarded as the utmost expression of the system 's purposefulness. This is to be achieved by ensuring the participation of all the stakeholders who affect, or are affected by, a particular business system's operations. The nature of participation, defined as a process of the stakeholders' perceptual exchanges, is deemed to be problematic in itself, due to the influence exerted upon it by organisational power, coercion and false consciousness. The paper highlights the philosophical reasons for the failures of information systems development methodologies, and provides a conceptual solution to this problematic as well as a strategy for the development of intrinsically motivated organisational information systems. The intrinsically motivated information systems methodology outlined here (BSPA) is intended to yield organisational information systems that demonstrably improve co-ordination of organisational activities, by enabling the development and maintenance of a single/multifaceted view of purpose throughout organisations.

KW - business systems

KW - coercion

KW - complementarism

KW - false consciousness

KW - methodology

KW - power

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035620694&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1023/A:1011400409028

DO - 10.1023/A:1011400409028

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 211

EP - 226

JO - Information Systems Frontiers

JF - Information Systems Frontiers

SN - 1387-3326

IS - 2

ER -