Francisco Suárez on consent and political obligation

Daniel Schwartz*

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Interpreters disagree on the origin that Francisco Suárez assigns to political obligation and correlative political subjection. According to some, Suárez, as other social contract theorists, believes that it is the consent of the individuals that causes political obligation. Others, however, claim that for Suárez, political obligation is underived from the individuals' consent which creates the city. In support of this claim they invoke Suárez's view that political power emanates from the city by way of "natural resultancy". I argue that analysis of Suárez's less studied De voto and De iuramento reveals that, for Suárez, consent causes both the city and the citizen's political obligation. Moreover, close inspection of the notion of causation by natural resultancy within Suárez's metaphysics shows that what emanates from the body politic in this fashion is not, as claimed, political subjection and political obligation, but rather the city's right to self-mastership. Because for him political obligation does originate in consent it is not incorrect to regard Suárez as a social contract theorist.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)59-81
Number of pages23
JournalVivarium
Volume46
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2008

Fingerprint

Consent
Political Obligation
Theorists
Social Contract
Subjection
Causes
Metaphysics
Interpreter
Political Power
Causation
Body Politics

Keywords

  • consent
  • Francisco Suárez
  • natural resultancy
  • political obligation
  • political power

Cite this

Schwartz, Daniel. / Francisco Suárez on consent and political obligation. In: Vivarium. 2008 ; Vol. 46, No. 1. pp. 59-81.
@article{89914ef7c5db4c1298053c6677b98127,
title = "Francisco Su{\'a}rez on consent and political obligation",
abstract = "Interpreters disagree on the origin that Francisco Su{\'a}rez assigns to political obligation and correlative political subjection. According to some, Su{\'a}rez, as other social contract theorists, believes that it is the consent of the individuals that causes political obligation. Others, however, claim that for Su{\'a}rez, political obligation is underived from the individuals' consent which creates the city. In support of this claim they invoke Su{\'a}rez's view that political power emanates from the city by way of {"}natural resultancy{"}. I argue that analysis of Su{\'a}rez's less studied De voto and De iuramento reveals that, for Su{\'a}rez, consent causes both the city and the citizen's political obligation. Moreover, close inspection of the notion of causation by natural resultancy within Su{\'a}rez's metaphysics shows that what emanates from the body politic in this fashion is not, as claimed, political subjection and political obligation, but rather the city's right to self-mastership. Because for him political obligation does originate in consent it is not incorrect to regard Su{\'a}rez as a social contract theorist.",
keywords = "consent, Francisco Su{\'a}rez, natural resultancy, political obligation, political power",
author = "Daniel Schwartz",
year = "2008",
doi = "10.1163/156853408X252768",
language = "English",
volume = "46",
pages = "59--81",
journal = "Vivarium",
issn = "0042-7543",
publisher = "Brill",
number = "1",

}

Francisco Suárez on consent and political obligation. / Schwartz, Daniel.

In: Vivarium, Vol. 46, No. 1, 2008, p. 59-81.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Francisco Suárez on consent and political obligation

AU - Schwartz, Daniel

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - Interpreters disagree on the origin that Francisco Suárez assigns to political obligation and correlative political subjection. According to some, Suárez, as other social contract theorists, believes that it is the consent of the individuals that causes political obligation. Others, however, claim that for Suárez, political obligation is underived from the individuals' consent which creates the city. In support of this claim they invoke Suárez's view that political power emanates from the city by way of "natural resultancy". I argue that analysis of Suárez's less studied De voto and De iuramento reveals that, for Suárez, consent causes both the city and the citizen's political obligation. Moreover, close inspection of the notion of causation by natural resultancy within Suárez's metaphysics shows that what emanates from the body politic in this fashion is not, as claimed, political subjection and political obligation, but rather the city's right to self-mastership. Because for him political obligation does originate in consent it is not incorrect to regard Suárez as a social contract theorist.

AB - Interpreters disagree on the origin that Francisco Suárez assigns to political obligation and correlative political subjection. According to some, Suárez, as other social contract theorists, believes that it is the consent of the individuals that causes political obligation. Others, however, claim that for Suárez, political obligation is underived from the individuals' consent which creates the city. In support of this claim they invoke Suárez's view that political power emanates from the city by way of "natural resultancy". I argue that analysis of Suárez's less studied De voto and De iuramento reveals that, for Suárez, consent causes both the city and the citizen's political obligation. Moreover, close inspection of the notion of causation by natural resultancy within Suárez's metaphysics shows that what emanates from the body politic in this fashion is not, as claimed, political subjection and political obligation, but rather the city's right to self-mastership. Because for him political obligation does originate in consent it is not incorrect to regard Suárez as a social contract theorist.

KW - consent

KW - Francisco Suárez

KW - natural resultancy

KW - political obligation

KW - political power

UR - http://booksandjournals.brillonline.com/content/journals/10.1163/156853408x252768

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=38049144117&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1163/156853408X252768

DO - 10.1163/156853408X252768

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:38049144117

VL - 46

SP - 59

EP - 81

JO - Vivarium

JF - Vivarium

SN - 0042-7543

IS - 1

ER -