Joining the dots: using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection

Panos Vlachopoulos*, Anne Wheeler

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Although there has been an increased interest in the use of electronic portfolios in higher education over the last five years, relatively little is known about the potential of such tools to support the development of higher order abilities for students, such as reflection, in a structured way that is suitable for assessment. This paper reports the findings from a small-scale research which sets out to compare the outcomes of reflective assignments in two cohorts of participants in a Postgraduate Certificate in Professional Practice in Higher Education in the UK. Participants in the programme were asked to submit reflective accounts using an e-portfolio system as part of their formal assessment. One cohort completed the assessment using some generic guidelines of how to reflect and construct an e-portfolio page without a given template or structure, whereas another cohort was given a specific template with clear assessment criteria to gauge the assembly of their reflections. The authors, who are also tutors in the programme, analysed the submitted reflections following open coding procedures. The analysis found a tendency for the reflection in the first cohort to be merely descriptive without progressing to speculating objectively about answers to relevant analytical questions about the process involved in the ability under scrutiny. In contrast the assignments of cohort two were found to be more insightful in terms of assimilating random bits of materials, thoughts and self-questions into complete reflective accounts. These findings bring some evidence to support and indeed promote a more structured approach to reflective practice, which can be further enhanced through a carefully created e-portfolio template and associated assessment criteria.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings
EditorsH. Carter, M. Gosper, J. Hedberg
Place of PublicationSydney (AU)
PublisherMacquarie University
Pages879-882
Number of pages4
ISBN (Print)978-1-74138-403-1
Publication statusPublished - 2013
Event30th annual conference on Australian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education - Sydney, Australia
Duration: 1 Dec 20134 Dec 2013

Conference

Conference30th annual conference on Australian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education
Abbreviated titleASCILITE 2013
CountryAustralia
CitySydney
Period1/12/134/12/13

Fingerprint

Joining
assessment criteria
Education
ability
tutor
certification
coding
education
electronics
Gages
Students
evidence
student

Keywords

  • assessment criteria
  • e-portfolios
  • reflective practice
  • templates

Cite this

Vlachopoulos, P., & Wheeler, A. (2013). Joining the dots: using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection. In H. Carter, M. Gosper, & J. Hedberg (Eds.), 30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings (pp. 879-882). Sydney (AU): Macquarie University.
Vlachopoulos, Panos ; Wheeler, Anne. / Joining the dots : using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection. 30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings. editor / H. Carter ; M. Gosper ; J. Hedberg. Sydney (AU) : Macquarie University, 2013. pp. 879-882
@inproceedings{53222794a1404d429a3726cfda2c079b,
title = "Joining the dots: using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection",
abstract = "Although there has been an increased interest in the use of electronic portfolios in higher education over the last five years, relatively little is known about the potential of such tools to support the development of higher order abilities for students, such as reflection, in a structured way that is suitable for assessment. This paper reports the findings from a small-scale research which sets out to compare the outcomes of reflective assignments in two cohorts of participants in a Postgraduate Certificate in Professional Practice in Higher Education in the UK. Participants in the programme were asked to submit reflective accounts using an e-portfolio system as part of their formal assessment. One cohort completed the assessment using some generic guidelines of how to reflect and construct an e-portfolio page without a given template or structure, whereas another cohort was given a specific template with clear assessment criteria to gauge the assembly of their reflections. The authors, who are also tutors in the programme, analysed the submitted reflections following open coding procedures. The analysis found a tendency for the reflection in the first cohort to be merely descriptive without progressing to speculating objectively about answers to relevant analytical questions about the process involved in the ability under scrutiny. In contrast the assignments of cohort two were found to be more insightful in terms of assimilating random bits of materials, thoughts and self-questions into complete reflective accounts. These findings bring some evidence to support and indeed promote a more structured approach to reflective practice, which can be further enhanced through a carefully created e-portfolio template and associated assessment criteria.",
keywords = "assessment criteria, e-portfolios, reflective practice, templates",
author = "Panos Vlachopoulos and Anne Wheeler",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-1-74138-403-1",
pages = "879--882",
editor = "H. Carter and M. Gosper and J. Hedberg",
booktitle = "30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings",
publisher = "Macquarie University",

}

Vlachopoulos, P & Wheeler, A 2013, Joining the dots: using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection. in H Carter, M Gosper & J Hedberg (eds), 30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings. Macquarie University, Sydney (AU), pp. 879-882, 30th annual conference on Australian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education, Sydney, Australia, 1/12/13.

Joining the dots : using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection. / Vlachopoulos, Panos; Wheeler, Anne.

30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings. ed. / H. Carter; M. Gosper; J. Hedberg. Sydney (AU) : Macquarie University, 2013. p. 879-882.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Joining the dots

T2 - using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection

AU - Vlachopoulos, Panos

AU - Wheeler, Anne

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Although there has been an increased interest in the use of electronic portfolios in higher education over the last five years, relatively little is known about the potential of such tools to support the development of higher order abilities for students, such as reflection, in a structured way that is suitable for assessment. This paper reports the findings from a small-scale research which sets out to compare the outcomes of reflective assignments in two cohorts of participants in a Postgraduate Certificate in Professional Practice in Higher Education in the UK. Participants in the programme were asked to submit reflective accounts using an e-portfolio system as part of their formal assessment. One cohort completed the assessment using some generic guidelines of how to reflect and construct an e-portfolio page without a given template or structure, whereas another cohort was given a specific template with clear assessment criteria to gauge the assembly of their reflections. The authors, who are also tutors in the programme, analysed the submitted reflections following open coding procedures. The analysis found a tendency for the reflection in the first cohort to be merely descriptive without progressing to speculating objectively about answers to relevant analytical questions about the process involved in the ability under scrutiny. In contrast the assignments of cohort two were found to be more insightful in terms of assimilating random bits of materials, thoughts and self-questions into complete reflective accounts. These findings bring some evidence to support and indeed promote a more structured approach to reflective practice, which can be further enhanced through a carefully created e-portfolio template and associated assessment criteria.

AB - Although there has been an increased interest in the use of electronic portfolios in higher education over the last five years, relatively little is known about the potential of such tools to support the development of higher order abilities for students, such as reflection, in a structured way that is suitable for assessment. This paper reports the findings from a small-scale research which sets out to compare the outcomes of reflective assignments in two cohorts of participants in a Postgraduate Certificate in Professional Practice in Higher Education in the UK. Participants in the programme were asked to submit reflective accounts using an e-portfolio system as part of their formal assessment. One cohort completed the assessment using some generic guidelines of how to reflect and construct an e-portfolio page without a given template or structure, whereas another cohort was given a specific template with clear assessment criteria to gauge the assembly of their reflections. The authors, who are also tutors in the programme, analysed the submitted reflections following open coding procedures. The analysis found a tendency for the reflection in the first cohort to be merely descriptive without progressing to speculating objectively about answers to relevant analytical questions about the process involved in the ability under scrutiny. In contrast the assignments of cohort two were found to be more insightful in terms of assimilating random bits of materials, thoughts and self-questions into complete reflective accounts. These findings bring some evidence to support and indeed promote a more structured approach to reflective practice, which can be further enhanced through a carefully created e-portfolio template and associated assessment criteria.

KW - assessment criteria

KW - e-portfolios

KW - reflective practice

KW - templates

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84913599269&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.ascilite.org/conferences/sydney13/program/papers/Vlachopoulos.pdf

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:84913599269

SN - 978-1-74138-403-1

SP - 879

EP - 882

BT - 30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings

A2 - Carter, H.

A2 - Gosper, M.

A2 - Hedberg, J.

PB - Macquarie University

CY - Sydney (AU)

ER -

Vlachopoulos P, Wheeler A. Joining the dots: using structured e-portfolio assignments to enhance reflection. In Carter H, Gosper M, Hedberg J, editors, 30th ascilite conference 2013 proceedings. Sydney (AU): Macquarie University. 2013. p. 879-882