Kant and Darwin

Christopher U.M. Smith

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    The central theses of Kant's critical philosophy are sometimes said to have been overtaken by evolutionary biology. This paper considers how far this proposition can be sustained. I argue that the ‘architectonic’ or ‘system-building’ character of the mind, the categories and the forms of intuition, can indeed be seen as the outcome of a particular evolutionary lineage in a Darwinian world. I argue, further, that the principal motive energizing the critical philosophy is the 'nightmare' of physical determinism. An alternative escape route from this particular nightmare is rehearsed. If this route is taken, the intricate arguments of the Critiques are unnecessary to save moral action in a world of things. Nonetheless, insofar as 'first philosophy' necessarily starts from within the philosopher's own subjectivity, Kant's work retains its power. I suggest that the Kantian and the Darwinian interpretations are to an extent complementary. If this is so, some form of evolutionarily-informed dual-aspect psychoneural identity theory could combine the essence of the two interpretations.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)35-50
    Number of pages16
    JournalJournal of Social and Biological Structures
    Volume14
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1991

    Fingerprint

    Intuition
    Power (Psychology)

    Keywords

    • Kant
    • critical philosophy
    • evolutionary biology
    • character of the mind
    • intuition
    • evolutionary lineage
    • Darwin
    • physical determinism
    • psychoneural identity

    Cite this

    Smith, Christopher U.M. / Kant and Darwin. In: Journal of Social and Biological Structures. 1991 ; Vol. 14, No. 1. pp. 35-50.
    @article{be327c8465eb4a168d0d5d1b0e17859a,
    title = "Kant and Darwin",
    abstract = "The central theses of Kant's critical philosophy are sometimes said to have been overtaken by evolutionary biology. This paper considers how far this proposition can be sustained. I argue that the ‘architectonic’ or ‘system-building’ character of the mind, the categories and the forms of intuition, can indeed be seen as the outcome of a particular evolutionary lineage in a Darwinian world. I argue, further, that the principal motive energizing the critical philosophy is the 'nightmare' of physical determinism. An alternative escape route from this particular nightmare is rehearsed. If this route is taken, the intricate arguments of the Critiques are unnecessary to save moral action in a world of things. Nonetheless, insofar as 'first philosophy' necessarily starts from within the philosopher's own subjectivity, Kant's work retains its power. I suggest that the Kantian and the Darwinian interpretations are to an extent complementary. If this is so, some form of evolutionarily-informed dual-aspect psychoneural identity theory could combine the essence of the two interpretations.",
    keywords = "Kant, critical philosophy, evolutionary biology, character of the mind, intuition, evolutionary lineage, Darwin, physical determinism, psychoneural identity",
    author = "Smith, {Christopher U.M.}",
    year = "1991",
    doi = "10.1016/0140-1750(91)90023-J",
    language = "English",
    volume = "14",
    pages = "35--50",
    journal = "Journal of Social and Biological Structures",
    issn = "0140-1750",
    publisher = "Academic Press",
    number = "1",

    }

    Kant and Darwin. / Smith, Christopher U.M.

    In: Journal of Social and Biological Structures, Vol. 14, No. 1, 1991, p. 35-50.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Kant and Darwin

    AU - Smith, Christopher U.M.

    PY - 1991

    Y1 - 1991

    N2 - The central theses of Kant's critical philosophy are sometimes said to have been overtaken by evolutionary biology. This paper considers how far this proposition can be sustained. I argue that the ‘architectonic’ or ‘system-building’ character of the mind, the categories and the forms of intuition, can indeed be seen as the outcome of a particular evolutionary lineage in a Darwinian world. I argue, further, that the principal motive energizing the critical philosophy is the 'nightmare' of physical determinism. An alternative escape route from this particular nightmare is rehearsed. If this route is taken, the intricate arguments of the Critiques are unnecessary to save moral action in a world of things. Nonetheless, insofar as 'first philosophy' necessarily starts from within the philosopher's own subjectivity, Kant's work retains its power. I suggest that the Kantian and the Darwinian interpretations are to an extent complementary. If this is so, some form of evolutionarily-informed dual-aspect psychoneural identity theory could combine the essence of the two interpretations.

    AB - The central theses of Kant's critical philosophy are sometimes said to have been overtaken by evolutionary biology. This paper considers how far this proposition can be sustained. I argue that the ‘architectonic’ or ‘system-building’ character of the mind, the categories and the forms of intuition, can indeed be seen as the outcome of a particular evolutionary lineage in a Darwinian world. I argue, further, that the principal motive energizing the critical philosophy is the 'nightmare' of physical determinism. An alternative escape route from this particular nightmare is rehearsed. If this route is taken, the intricate arguments of the Critiques are unnecessary to save moral action in a world of things. Nonetheless, insofar as 'first philosophy' necessarily starts from within the philosopher's own subjectivity, Kant's work retains its power. I suggest that the Kantian and the Darwinian interpretations are to an extent complementary. If this is so, some form of evolutionarily-informed dual-aspect psychoneural identity theory could combine the essence of the two interpretations.

    KW - Kant

    KW - critical philosophy

    KW - evolutionary biology

    KW - character of the mind

    KW - intuition

    KW - evolutionary lineage

    KW - Darwin

    KW - physical determinism

    KW - psychoneural identity

    UR - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/014017509190023J?via%3Dihub

    U2 - 10.1016/0140-1750(91)90023-J

    DO - 10.1016/0140-1750(91)90023-J

    M3 - Article

    VL - 14

    SP - 35

    EP - 50

    JO - Journal of Social and Biological Structures

    JF - Journal of Social and Biological Structures

    SN - 0140-1750

    IS - 1

    ER -