Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem

Christopher Brewster

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Knowledge maintenance is a major challenge for both knowledge management and the Semantic Web. Operating over the Semantic Web, there will be a network of collaborating agents, each with their own ontologies or knowledge bases. Change in the knowledge state of one agent may need to be propagated across a number of agents and their associated ontologies. The challenge is to decide how to propagate a change of knowledge state. The effects of a change in knowledge state cannot be known in advance, and so an agent cannot know who should be informed unless it adopts a simple ‘tell everyone – everything’ strategy. This situation is highly reminiscent of the classic Frame Problem in AI. We argue that for agent-based technologies to succeed, far greater attention must be given to creating an appropriate model for knowledge update. In a closed system, simple strategies are possible (e.g. ‘sleeping dog’ or ‘cheap test’ or even complete checking). However, in an open system where cause and effect are unpredictable, a coherent cost-benefit based model of agent interaction is essential. Otherwise, the effectiveness of every act of knowledge update/maintenance is brought into question.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication[Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]
Number of pages5
Publication statusPublished - 2003
Event6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium - Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Duration: 6 Jan 20037 Jan 2003

Conference

Conference6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityEdinburgh
Period6/01/037/01/03

Fingerprint

Semantic Web
Ontology
Open systems
Knowledge management
Costs

Keywords

  • knowledge maintenance

Cite this

Brewster, C. (2003). Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem. In [Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]
Brewster, Christopher. / Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem. [Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]. 2003.
@inbook{8c7e166024cb4e61a4b1781091d24d80,
title = "Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem",
abstract = "Knowledge maintenance is a major challenge for both knowledge management and the Semantic Web. Operating over the Semantic Web, there will be a network of collaborating agents, each with their own ontologies or knowledge bases. Change in the knowledge state of one agent may need to be propagated across a number of agents and their associated ontologies. The challenge is to decide how to propagate a change of knowledge state. The effects of a change in knowledge state cannot be known in advance, and so an agent cannot know who should be informed unless it adopts a simple ‘tell everyone – everything’ strategy. This situation is highly reminiscent of the classic Frame Problem in AI. We argue that for agent-based technologies to succeed, far greater attention must be given to creating an appropriate model for knowledge update. In a closed system, simple strategies are possible (e.g. ‘sleeping dog’ or ‘cheap test’ or even complete checking). However, in an open system where cause and effect are unpredictable, a coherent cost-benefit based model of agent interaction is essential. Otherwise, the effectiveness of every act of knowledge update/maintenance is brought into question.",
keywords = "knowledge maintenance",
author = "Christopher Brewster",
year = "2003",
language = "English",
booktitle = "[Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]",

}

Brewster, C 2003, Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem. in [Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]. 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 6/01/03.

Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem. / Brewster, Christopher.

[Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]. 2003.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem

AU - Brewster, Christopher

PY - 2003

Y1 - 2003

N2 - Knowledge maintenance is a major challenge for both knowledge management and the Semantic Web. Operating over the Semantic Web, there will be a network of collaborating agents, each with their own ontologies or knowledge bases. Change in the knowledge state of one agent may need to be propagated across a number of agents and their associated ontologies. The challenge is to decide how to propagate a change of knowledge state. The effects of a change in knowledge state cannot be known in advance, and so an agent cannot know who should be informed unless it adopts a simple ‘tell everyone – everything’ strategy. This situation is highly reminiscent of the classic Frame Problem in AI. We argue that for agent-based technologies to succeed, far greater attention must be given to creating an appropriate model for knowledge update. In a closed system, simple strategies are possible (e.g. ‘sleeping dog’ or ‘cheap test’ or even complete checking). However, in an open system where cause and effect are unpredictable, a coherent cost-benefit based model of agent interaction is essential. Otherwise, the effectiveness of every act of knowledge update/maintenance is brought into question.

AB - Knowledge maintenance is a major challenge for both knowledge management and the Semantic Web. Operating over the Semantic Web, there will be a network of collaborating agents, each with their own ontologies or knowledge bases. Change in the knowledge state of one agent may need to be propagated across a number of agents and their associated ontologies. The challenge is to decide how to propagate a change of knowledge state. The effects of a change in knowledge state cannot be known in advance, and so an agent cannot know who should be informed unless it adopts a simple ‘tell everyone – everything’ strategy. This situation is highly reminiscent of the classic Frame Problem in AI. We argue that for agent-based technologies to succeed, far greater attention must be given to creating an appropriate model for knowledge update. In a closed system, simple strategies are possible (e.g. ‘sleeping dog’ or ‘cheap test’ or even complete checking). However, in an open system where cause and effect are unpredictable, a coherent cost-benefit based model of agent interaction is essential. Otherwise, the effectiveness of every act of knowledge update/maintenance is brought into question.

KW - knowledge maintenance

M3 - Chapter

BT - [Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]

ER -

Brewster C. Knowledge maintenance and the frame problem. In [Proceedings of the 6th Annual CLUK Research Colloquium]. 2003