Perception of Mach bands may be explained by spatial filtering ('lateral inhibition') that can be approximated by 2nd derivative computation, and several alternative models have been proposed. To distinguish between them, we used a novel set of ‘generalised Gaussian’ images, in which the sharp ramp-plateau junction of the Mach ramp was replaced by smoother transitions. The images ranged from a slightly blurred Mach ramp to a Gaussian edge and beyond, and also included a sine-wave edge. The probability of seeing Mach Bands increased with the (relative) sharpness of the junction, but was largely independent of absolute spatial scale. These data did not fit the predictions of MIRAGE, nor 2nd derivative computation at a single fine scale. In experiment 2, observers used a cursor to mark features on the same set of images. Data on perceived position of Mach bands did not support the local energy model. Perceived width of Mach bands was poorly explained by a single-scale edge detection model, despite its previous success with Mach edges (Wallis & Georgeson, 2009, Vision Research, 49, 1886-1893). A more successful model used separate (odd and even) scale-space filtering for edges and bars, local peak detection to find candidate features, and the MAX operator to compare odd- and even-filter response maps (Georgeson, VSS 2006, Journal of Vision 6(6), 191a). Mach bands are seen when there is a local peak in the even-filter (bar) response map, AND that peak value exceeds corresponding responses in the odd-filter (edge) maps.
|Publication status||Unpublished - 18 Dec 2010|
|Event||Fourteenth Applied Vision Association Christmas Meeting - University of Bristol, Bristol (UK)|
Duration: 18 Dec 2009 → …
|Other||Fourteenth Applied Vision Association Christmas Meeting|
|City||University of Bristol, Bristol (UK)|
|Period||18/12/09 → …|
Bibliographical noteAbstract published in Fourteenth Applied Vision Association Christmas Meeting, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK, 18 December 2009, Abstracts, Perception, (2010) 39 (2), p.272, 0301-0066.
- Mach bands
- spatial filtering
- lateral inhibition
- 2nd derivative computation
- generalised Gaussian images
- sharp ramp-plateau junction
- Gaussian edge
- sine-wave edge