Orthogonal-compatibility effects confound automatic imitation: implications for measuring self–other distinction

Daniel Joel Shaw, Kristína Czekóová, Michaela Porubanová

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Accurate distinction between self and other representations is fundamental to a range of social cognitive capacities, and understanding individual differences in this ability is an important aim for psychological research. This demands accurate measures of self–other distinction (SOD). The present study examined an experimental paradigm employed frequently to measure SOD in the action domain; specifically, we evaluated the rotated finger-action stimuli used increasingly to measure automatic imitation (AI). To assess the suitability of these stimuli, we compared AI elicited by different action stimuli to the performance on a perspective-taking task believed to measure SOD in the perception domain. In two separate experiments we reveal three important findings: firstly, we demonstrate a strong confounding influence of orthogonal-compatibility effects on AI elicited by certain rotated stimuli. Second, we demonstrate the potential for this confounding influence to mask important relationships between AI and other measures of SOD; we observed a relationship between AI and perspective-taking performance only when the former was measured in isolation of orthogonality compatibility. Thirdly, we observed a relationship between these two performance measures only in a sub-group of individuals exhibiting a pure form of AI. Furthermore, this relationship revealed a self-bias in SOD—reduced AI was associated with increased egocentric misattributions in perspective taking. Together, our findings identify an important methodological consideration for measures of AI and extend previous research by showing an egocentric style of SOD across action and perception domains.

LanguageEnglish
Pages1152-1165
Number of pages14
JournalPsychological Research
Volume81
Issue number6
Early online date17 Oct 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2016

Fingerprint

Aptitude
Ego
Masks
Research
Individuality
Fingers
Psychology
Compatibility
Imitation
Stimulus
Perspective Taking

Cite this

@article{04969fb1059147b7b5730fde2783fdb4,
title = "Orthogonal-compatibility effects confound automatic imitation: implications for measuring self–other distinction",
abstract = "Accurate distinction between self and other representations is fundamental to a range of social cognitive capacities, and understanding individual differences in this ability is an important aim for psychological research. This demands accurate measures of self–other distinction (SOD). The present study examined an experimental paradigm employed frequently to measure SOD in the action domain; specifically, we evaluated the rotated finger-action stimuli used increasingly to measure automatic imitation (AI). To assess the suitability of these stimuli, we compared AI elicited by different action stimuli to the performance on a perspective-taking task believed to measure SOD in the perception domain. In two separate experiments we reveal three important findings: firstly, we demonstrate a strong confounding influence of orthogonal-compatibility effects on AI elicited by certain rotated stimuli. Second, we demonstrate the potential for this confounding influence to mask important relationships between AI and other measures of SOD; we observed a relationship between AI and perspective-taking performance only when the former was measured in isolation of orthogonality compatibility. Thirdly, we observed a relationship between these two performance measures only in a sub-group of individuals exhibiting a pure form of AI. Furthermore, this relationship revealed a self-bias in SOD—reduced AI was associated with increased egocentric misattributions in perspective taking. Together, our findings identify an important methodological consideration for measures of AI and extend previous research by showing an egocentric style of SOD across action and perception domains.",
author = "Shaw, {Daniel Joel} and Krist{\'i}na Czek{\'o}ov{\'a} and Michaela Porubanov{\'a}",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s00426-016-0814-x",
language = "English",
volume = "81",
pages = "1152--1165",
journal = "Psychological Research",
issn = "0340-0727",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "6",

}

Orthogonal-compatibility effects confound automatic imitation : implications for measuring self–other distinction. / Shaw, Daniel Joel; Czekóová, Kristína; Porubanová, Michaela.

In: Psychological Research, Vol. 81, No. 6, 01.11.2016, p. 1152-1165.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Orthogonal-compatibility effects confound automatic imitation

T2 - Psychological Research

AU - Shaw, Daniel Joel

AU - Czekóová, Kristína

AU - Porubanová, Michaela

PY - 2016/11/1

Y1 - 2016/11/1

N2 - Accurate distinction between self and other representations is fundamental to a range of social cognitive capacities, and understanding individual differences in this ability is an important aim for psychological research. This demands accurate measures of self–other distinction (SOD). The present study examined an experimental paradigm employed frequently to measure SOD in the action domain; specifically, we evaluated the rotated finger-action stimuli used increasingly to measure automatic imitation (AI). To assess the suitability of these stimuli, we compared AI elicited by different action stimuli to the performance on a perspective-taking task believed to measure SOD in the perception domain. In two separate experiments we reveal three important findings: firstly, we demonstrate a strong confounding influence of orthogonal-compatibility effects on AI elicited by certain rotated stimuli. Second, we demonstrate the potential for this confounding influence to mask important relationships between AI and other measures of SOD; we observed a relationship between AI and perspective-taking performance only when the former was measured in isolation of orthogonality compatibility. Thirdly, we observed a relationship between these two performance measures only in a sub-group of individuals exhibiting a pure form of AI. Furthermore, this relationship revealed a self-bias in SOD—reduced AI was associated with increased egocentric misattributions in perspective taking. Together, our findings identify an important methodological consideration for measures of AI and extend previous research by showing an egocentric style of SOD across action and perception domains.

AB - Accurate distinction between self and other representations is fundamental to a range of social cognitive capacities, and understanding individual differences in this ability is an important aim for psychological research. This demands accurate measures of self–other distinction (SOD). The present study examined an experimental paradigm employed frequently to measure SOD in the action domain; specifically, we evaluated the rotated finger-action stimuli used increasingly to measure automatic imitation (AI). To assess the suitability of these stimuli, we compared AI elicited by different action stimuli to the performance on a perspective-taking task believed to measure SOD in the perception domain. In two separate experiments we reveal three important findings: firstly, we demonstrate a strong confounding influence of orthogonal-compatibility effects on AI elicited by certain rotated stimuli. Second, we demonstrate the potential for this confounding influence to mask important relationships between AI and other measures of SOD; we observed a relationship between AI and perspective-taking performance only when the former was measured in isolation of orthogonality compatibility. Thirdly, we observed a relationship between these two performance measures only in a sub-group of individuals exhibiting a pure form of AI. Furthermore, this relationship revealed a self-bias in SOD—reduced AI was associated with increased egocentric misattributions in perspective taking. Together, our findings identify an important methodological consideration for measures of AI and extend previous research by showing an egocentric style of SOD across action and perception domains.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84991575844&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00426-016-0814-x

DO - 10.1007/s00426-016-0814-x

M3 - Article

VL - 81

SP - 1152

EP - 1165

JO - Psychological Research

JF - Psychological Research

SN - 0340-0727

IS - 6

ER -