Talking about depression: an analogue study of physician gender and communication style on patient disclosures

Debra L. Roter, Lori H. Erby, Ann Adams, Christopher D. Buckingham, Laura Vail, Alba Realpe, Susan Larson, Judith A. Hall

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objectives: To disentangle the effects of physician gender and patient-centered communication style on patients' oral engagement in depression care. Methods: Physician gender, physician race and communication style (high patient-centered (HPC) and low patient-centered (LPC)) were manipulated and presented as videotaped actors within a computer simulated medical visit to assess effects on analogue patient (AP) verbal responsiveness and care ratings. 307 APs (56% female; 70% African American) were randomly assigned to conditions and instructed to verbally respond to depression-related questions and indicate willingness to continue care. Disclosures were coded using Roter Interaction Analysis System (RIAS). Results: Both male and female APs talked more overall and conveyed more psychosocial and emotional talk to HPC gender discordant doctors (all p <.05). APs were more willing to continue treatment with gender-discordant HPC physicians (p <.05). No effects were evident in the LPC condition. Conclusions: Findings highlight a role for physician gender when considering active patient engagement in patient-centered depression care. This pattern suggests that there may be largely under-appreciated and consequential effects associated with patient expectations in regard to physician gender that these differ by patient gender. Practice implications: High patient-centeredness increases active patient engagement in depression care especially in gender discordant dyads.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)339–345
Number of pages7
JournalPatient Education and Counseling
Volume96
Issue number3
Early online date14 May 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2014
EventInternational Conference on Communication in Healthcare - Montreal, Canada
Duration: 29 Sep 20132 Oct 2013

Fingerprint

Disclosure
Communication
Depression
Physicians
Patient Participation
Physician's Role
Patient-Centered Care
African Americans

Bibliographical note

Communication in Healthcare: Lessons from Diversity — Best papers from the International Conference on Communication in Healthcare, Montreal, Canada, 29 September - 2 October 2013.

Funding: National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) R01MH086339 (Debra Roter, PI) “Understanding Social Contributions to Disparities in Depression Care: US and UK”. This program of research is also funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), grant RES-177-25-0014, which forms part of the ESRC/NIH Disparities Initiative.

Keywords

  • depression
  • patient-centeredness
  • RIAS
  • analogue patients
  • patient–physician communication
  • gender concordance

Cite this

Roter, Debra L. ; Erby, Lori H. ; Adams, Ann ; Buckingham, Christopher D. ; Vail, Laura ; Realpe, Alba ; Larson, Susan ; Hall, Judith A. / Talking about depression : an analogue study of physician gender and communication style on patient disclosures. In: Patient Education and Counseling. 2014 ; Vol. 96, No. 3. pp. 339–345.
@article{5ba1c36b572f4adc802e20cba0fe4e0e,
title = "Talking about depression: an analogue study of physician gender and communication style on patient disclosures",
abstract = "Objectives: To disentangle the effects of physician gender and patient-centered communication style on patients' oral engagement in depression care. Methods: Physician gender, physician race and communication style (high patient-centered (HPC) and low patient-centered (LPC)) were manipulated and presented as videotaped actors within a computer simulated medical visit to assess effects on analogue patient (AP) verbal responsiveness and care ratings. 307 APs (56{\%} female; 70{\%} African American) were randomly assigned to conditions and instructed to verbally respond to depression-related questions and indicate willingness to continue care. Disclosures were coded using Roter Interaction Analysis System (RIAS). Results: Both male and female APs talked more overall and conveyed more psychosocial and emotional talk to HPC gender discordant doctors (all p <.05). APs were more willing to continue treatment with gender-discordant HPC physicians (p <.05). No effects were evident in the LPC condition. Conclusions: Findings highlight a role for physician gender when considering active patient engagement in patient-centered depression care. This pattern suggests that there may be largely under-appreciated and consequential effects associated with patient expectations in regard to physician gender that these differ by patient gender. Practice implications: High patient-centeredness increases active patient engagement in depression care especially in gender discordant dyads.",
keywords = "depression, patient-centeredness, RIAS, analogue patients, patient–physician communication, gender concordance",
author = "Roter, {Debra L.} and Erby, {Lori H.} and Ann Adams and Buckingham, {Christopher D.} and Laura Vail and Alba Realpe and Susan Larson and Hall, {Judith A.}",
note = "Communication in Healthcare: Lessons from Diversity — Best papers from the International Conference on Communication in Healthcare, Montreal, Canada, 29 September - 2 October 2013. Funding: National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) R01MH086339 (Debra Roter, PI) “Understanding Social Contributions to Disparities in Depression Care: US and UK”. This program of research is also funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), grant RES-177-25-0014, which forms part of the ESRC/NIH Disparities Initiative.",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1016/j.pec.2014.05.006",
language = "English",
volume = "96",
pages = "339–345",
journal = "Patient Education and Counseling",
issn = "0738-3991",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "3",

}

Talking about depression : an analogue study of physician gender and communication style on patient disclosures. / Roter, Debra L.; Erby, Lori H.; Adams, Ann; Buckingham, Christopher D.; Vail, Laura; Realpe, Alba; Larson, Susan; Hall, Judith A.

In: Patient Education and Counseling, Vol. 96, No. 3, 09.2014, p. 339–345.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Talking about depression

T2 - an analogue study of physician gender and communication style on patient disclosures

AU - Roter, Debra L.

AU - Erby, Lori H.

AU - Adams, Ann

AU - Buckingham, Christopher D.

AU - Vail, Laura

AU - Realpe, Alba

AU - Larson, Susan

AU - Hall, Judith A.

N1 - Communication in Healthcare: Lessons from Diversity — Best papers from the International Conference on Communication in Healthcare, Montreal, Canada, 29 September - 2 October 2013. Funding: National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) R01MH086339 (Debra Roter, PI) “Understanding Social Contributions to Disparities in Depression Care: US and UK”. This program of research is also funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), grant RES-177-25-0014, which forms part of the ESRC/NIH Disparities Initiative.

PY - 2014/9

Y1 - 2014/9

N2 - Objectives: To disentangle the effects of physician gender and patient-centered communication style on patients' oral engagement in depression care. Methods: Physician gender, physician race and communication style (high patient-centered (HPC) and low patient-centered (LPC)) were manipulated and presented as videotaped actors within a computer simulated medical visit to assess effects on analogue patient (AP) verbal responsiveness and care ratings. 307 APs (56% female; 70% African American) were randomly assigned to conditions and instructed to verbally respond to depression-related questions and indicate willingness to continue care. Disclosures were coded using Roter Interaction Analysis System (RIAS). Results: Both male and female APs talked more overall and conveyed more psychosocial and emotional talk to HPC gender discordant doctors (all p <.05). APs were more willing to continue treatment with gender-discordant HPC physicians (p <.05). No effects were evident in the LPC condition. Conclusions: Findings highlight a role for physician gender when considering active patient engagement in patient-centered depression care. This pattern suggests that there may be largely under-appreciated and consequential effects associated with patient expectations in regard to physician gender that these differ by patient gender. Practice implications: High patient-centeredness increases active patient engagement in depression care especially in gender discordant dyads.

AB - Objectives: To disentangle the effects of physician gender and patient-centered communication style on patients' oral engagement in depression care. Methods: Physician gender, physician race and communication style (high patient-centered (HPC) and low patient-centered (LPC)) were manipulated and presented as videotaped actors within a computer simulated medical visit to assess effects on analogue patient (AP) verbal responsiveness and care ratings. 307 APs (56% female; 70% African American) were randomly assigned to conditions and instructed to verbally respond to depression-related questions and indicate willingness to continue care. Disclosures were coded using Roter Interaction Analysis System (RIAS). Results: Both male and female APs talked more overall and conveyed more psychosocial and emotional talk to HPC gender discordant doctors (all p <.05). APs were more willing to continue treatment with gender-discordant HPC physicians (p <.05). No effects were evident in the LPC condition. Conclusions: Findings highlight a role for physician gender when considering active patient engagement in patient-centered depression care. This pattern suggests that there may be largely under-appreciated and consequential effects associated with patient expectations in regard to physician gender that these differ by patient gender. Practice implications: High patient-centeredness increases active patient engagement in depression care especially in gender discordant dyads.

KW - depression

KW - patient-centeredness

KW - RIAS

KW - analogue patients

KW - patient–physician communication

KW - gender concordance

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84906791243&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.pec.2014.05.006

DO - 10.1016/j.pec.2014.05.006

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84906791243

VL - 96

SP - 339

EP - 345

JO - Patient Education and Counseling

JF - Patient Education and Counseling

SN - 0738-3991

IS - 3

ER -