TY - JOUR
T1 - Translation in XBRL standardization
AU - Troshani, Indrit
AU - Lymer, Andrew
PY - 2010/6/8
Y1 - 2010/6/8
N2 - Purpose: Extensible business reporting language (XBRL) presents new opportunities for integrating the flow of financial information within communities of diverse organizations, thereby significantly enhancing the business information supply chain and addressing existing efficiency, accuracy and transparency problems. Vital to its success, XBRL standardization is proving to be challenging. This paper aims to investigate the phenomena that occur when heterogeneous actors interact in attempts to standardize XBRL. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing upon actor-network theory (ANT) the authors "follow the actors" participating in the standardization of XBRL in Australia. Supporting qualitative empirical evidence was collected via interviews and reviews of XBRL artifacts and relevant technical documentation. Findings: The authors confirm the critical role of focal actors in standardizing XBRL in networks of heterogeneous actors. In addition to clear and indispensable value propositions and solid political and financial support, focal actors must also undertake effective problematization which can determine the manner in which interessement unfolds in their network. It is found that separation or even lack of alignment between technical standardization efforts and social and strategic orientation can be detrimental to translation effectiveness and network stability, and therefore, adversely affect standardization outcomes. Originality/value: By presenting unsuccessful and potentially successful focal actors side by side, the paper contributes to the current body of knowledge by enhancing current understanding of their role in achieving effective translations in XBRL standardization networks. It also provides the most analytical review to date of actor interaction in XBRL standardization in the literature.
AB - Purpose: Extensible business reporting language (XBRL) presents new opportunities for integrating the flow of financial information within communities of diverse organizations, thereby significantly enhancing the business information supply chain and addressing existing efficiency, accuracy and transparency problems. Vital to its success, XBRL standardization is proving to be challenging. This paper aims to investigate the phenomena that occur when heterogeneous actors interact in attempts to standardize XBRL. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing upon actor-network theory (ANT) the authors "follow the actors" participating in the standardization of XBRL in Australia. Supporting qualitative empirical evidence was collected via interviews and reviews of XBRL artifacts and relevant technical documentation. Findings: The authors confirm the critical role of focal actors in standardizing XBRL in networks of heterogeneous actors. In addition to clear and indispensable value propositions and solid political and financial support, focal actors must also undertake effective problematization which can determine the manner in which interessement unfolds in their network. It is found that separation or even lack of alignment between technical standardization efforts and social and strategic orientation can be detrimental to translation effectiveness and network stability, and therefore, adversely affect standardization outcomes. Originality/value: By presenting unsuccessful and potentially successful focal actors side by side, the paper contributes to the current body of knowledge by enhancing current understanding of their role in achieving effective translations in XBRL standardization networks. It also provides the most analytical review to date of actor interaction in XBRL standardization in the literature.
KW - Computer applications
KW - Extensible markup language
KW - Financial information
KW - Financial reporting
KW - Standardization
UR - https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/09593841011052147/full/html
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77952942753&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1108/09593841011052147
DO - 10.1108/09593841011052147
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:77952942753
SN - 0959-3845
VL - 23
SP - 136
EP - 164
JO - Information Technology and People
JF - Information Technology and People
IS - 2
ER -