When is an image a health claim? A false-recollection method to detect implicit inferences about products' health benefits

Naomi A. Klepacz, Robert A. Nash, M. Bernadette Egan, Charo E. Hodgkins, Monique M. Raats

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective: Images on food and dietary supplement packaging might lead people to infer (appropriately or inappropriately) certain health benefits of those products. Research on this issue largely involves direct questions, which could (a) elicit inferences that would not be made unprompted, and (b) fail to capture inferences made implicitly. Using a novel memory-based method, in the present research, we explored whether packaging imagery elicits health inferences without prompting, and the extent to which these inferences are made implicitly. Method: In 3 experiments, participants saw fictional product packages accompanied by written claims. Some packages contained an image that implied a health-related function (e.g., a brain), and some contained no image. Participants studied these packages and claims, and subsequently their memory for seen and unseen claims were tested. Results: When a health image was featured on a package, participants often subsequently recognized health claims that—despite being implied by the image—were not truly presented. In Experiment 2, these recognition errors persisted despite an explicit warning against treating the images as informative. In Experiment 3, these findings were replicated in a large consumer sample from 5 European countries, and with a cued-recall test. Conclusion: These findings confirm that images can act as health claims, by leading people to infer health benefits without prompting. These inferences appear often to be implicit, and could therefore be highly pervasive. The data underscore the importance of regulating imagery on product packaging; memory-based methods represent innovative ways to measure how leading (or misleading) specific images can be. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)
LanguageEnglish
Pages898-907
Number of pages10
JournalHealth Psychology
Volume35
Issue number8
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2016

Fingerprint

Insurance Benefits
Product Packaging
Health
Imagery (Psychotherapy)
Dietary Supplements
Research
Brain

Bibliographical note

This article may not exactly replicate the final version published in the APA journal. It is not the copy of record.

Funding: European Commission’s Seventh Framework Programme, within the CLYMBOL (Role of Health-Related Claims and Symbols in Consumer Behaviour; www.clymbol.eu) and PlantLIBRA (Plant food supplements: Levels of Intake, Benefit and Risk Assessment; www.plantlibra.eu) projects (Contract N°s: 311963 and 245199).

Keywords

  • health claims
  • imagery
  • memory
  • false recognition
  • inference

Cite this

Klepacz, Naomi A. ; Nash, Robert A. ; Egan, M. Bernadette ; Hodgkins, Charo E. ; Raats, Monique M. / When is an image a health claim? A false-recollection method to detect implicit inferences about products' health benefits. In: Health Psychology. 2016 ; Vol. 35, No. 8. pp. 898-907.
@article{73911bb4552941ee83911446c3b37636,
title = "When is an image a health claim? A false-recollection method to detect implicit inferences about products' health benefits",
abstract = "Objective: Images on food and dietary supplement packaging might lead people to infer (appropriately or inappropriately) certain health benefits of those products. Research on this issue largely involves direct questions, which could (a) elicit inferences that would not be made unprompted, and (b) fail to capture inferences made implicitly. Using a novel memory-based method, in the present research, we explored whether packaging imagery elicits health inferences without prompting, and the extent to which these inferences are made implicitly. Method: In 3 experiments, participants saw fictional product packages accompanied by written claims. Some packages contained an image that implied a health-related function (e.g., a brain), and some contained no image. Participants studied these packages and claims, and subsequently their memory for seen and unseen claims were tested. Results: When a health image was featured on a package, participants often subsequently recognized health claims that—despite being implied by the image—were not truly presented. In Experiment 2, these recognition errors persisted despite an explicit warning against treating the images as informative. In Experiment 3, these findings were replicated in a large consumer sample from 5 European countries, and with a cued-recall test. Conclusion: These findings confirm that images can act as health claims, by leading people to infer health benefits without prompting. These inferences appear often to be implicit, and could therefore be highly pervasive. The data underscore the importance of regulating imagery on product packaging; memory-based methods represent innovative ways to measure how leading (or misleading) specific images can be. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)",
keywords = "health claims, imagery, memory, false recognition, inference",
author = "Klepacz, {Naomi A.} and Nash, {Robert A.} and Egan, {M. Bernadette} and Hodgkins, {Charo E.} and Raats, {Monique M.}",
note = "This article may not exactly replicate the final version published in the APA journal. It is not the copy of record. Funding: European Commission’s Seventh Framework Programme, within the CLYMBOL (Role of Health-Related Claims and Symbols in Consumer Behaviour; www.clymbol.eu) and PlantLIBRA (Plant food supplements: Levels of Intake, Benefit and Risk Assessment; www.plantlibra.eu) projects (Contract N°s: 311963 and 245199).",
year = "2016",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1037/hea0000317",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "898--907",
journal = "Health Psychology",
issn = "0278-6133",
publisher = "American Psychological Association Inc.",
number = "8",

}

When is an image a health claim? A false-recollection method to detect implicit inferences about products' health benefits. / Klepacz, Naomi A.; Nash, Robert A.; Egan, M. Bernadette; Hodgkins, Charo E.; Raats, Monique M.

In: Health Psychology, Vol. 35, No. 8, 08.2016, p. 898-907.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - When is an image a health claim? A false-recollection method to detect implicit inferences about products' health benefits

AU - Klepacz, Naomi A.

AU - Nash, Robert A.

AU - Egan, M. Bernadette

AU - Hodgkins, Charo E.

AU - Raats, Monique M.

N1 - This article may not exactly replicate the final version published in the APA journal. It is not the copy of record. Funding: European Commission’s Seventh Framework Programme, within the CLYMBOL (Role of Health-Related Claims and Symbols in Consumer Behaviour; www.clymbol.eu) and PlantLIBRA (Plant food supplements: Levels of Intake, Benefit and Risk Assessment; www.plantlibra.eu) projects (Contract N°s: 311963 and 245199).

PY - 2016/8

Y1 - 2016/8

N2 - Objective: Images on food and dietary supplement packaging might lead people to infer (appropriately or inappropriately) certain health benefits of those products. Research on this issue largely involves direct questions, which could (a) elicit inferences that would not be made unprompted, and (b) fail to capture inferences made implicitly. Using a novel memory-based method, in the present research, we explored whether packaging imagery elicits health inferences without prompting, and the extent to which these inferences are made implicitly. Method: In 3 experiments, participants saw fictional product packages accompanied by written claims. Some packages contained an image that implied a health-related function (e.g., a brain), and some contained no image. Participants studied these packages and claims, and subsequently their memory for seen and unseen claims were tested. Results: When a health image was featured on a package, participants often subsequently recognized health claims that—despite being implied by the image—were not truly presented. In Experiment 2, these recognition errors persisted despite an explicit warning against treating the images as informative. In Experiment 3, these findings were replicated in a large consumer sample from 5 European countries, and with a cued-recall test. Conclusion: These findings confirm that images can act as health claims, by leading people to infer health benefits without prompting. These inferences appear often to be implicit, and could therefore be highly pervasive. The data underscore the importance of regulating imagery on product packaging; memory-based methods represent innovative ways to measure how leading (or misleading) specific images can be. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)

AB - Objective: Images on food and dietary supplement packaging might lead people to infer (appropriately or inappropriately) certain health benefits of those products. Research on this issue largely involves direct questions, which could (a) elicit inferences that would not be made unprompted, and (b) fail to capture inferences made implicitly. Using a novel memory-based method, in the present research, we explored whether packaging imagery elicits health inferences without prompting, and the extent to which these inferences are made implicitly. Method: In 3 experiments, participants saw fictional product packages accompanied by written claims. Some packages contained an image that implied a health-related function (e.g., a brain), and some contained no image. Participants studied these packages and claims, and subsequently their memory for seen and unseen claims were tested. Results: When a health image was featured on a package, participants often subsequently recognized health claims that—despite being implied by the image—were not truly presented. In Experiment 2, these recognition errors persisted despite an explicit warning against treating the images as informative. In Experiment 3, these findings were replicated in a large consumer sample from 5 European countries, and with a cued-recall test. Conclusion: These findings confirm that images can act as health claims, by leading people to infer health benefits without prompting. These inferences appear often to be implicit, and could therefore be highly pervasive. The data underscore the importance of regulating imagery on product packaging; memory-based methods represent innovative ways to measure how leading (or misleading) specific images can be. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)

KW - health claims

KW - imagery

KW - memory

KW - false recognition

KW - inference

U2 - 10.1037/hea0000317

DO - 10.1037/hea0000317

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 898

EP - 907

JO - Health Psychology

T2 - Health Psychology

JF - Health Psychology

SN - 0278-6133

IS - 8

ER -