Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

How Open Strategy Unfolds Without Design

  • Xiaohao Dai

    Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis › Doctor of Business Administration

    Abstract

    This research challenges the prevailing view in Open Strategy that openness should be
    planned and top-down designed. Instead, it investigates how open strategy can emerge
    organically without formal design. Situated within the Strategy-as-Practice (SAP)
    perspective, which views strategy as emerging from the everyday activities and microlevel practices of organizational actors, this study addresses a critical gap in understanding the bottom-up, emergent pathways to open strategy.

    The primary research question asks: how open strategy emerges organically, absent any
    formal design? This is unpacked through three sub-questions examining the micro-level
    initiation, meso-level sustaining mechanisms, and macro-level outcomes of such
    unplanned open initiatives.

    To answer these questions, a qualitative field study was conducted over three months
    within two private firms in China’s property management industry. This context was
    selected for its high-frequency, mundane stakeholder interactions and ongoing
    institutional flux, which create a fertile ground for observing organic emergence of open
    strategy.

    The analysis reveals that open strategy in these firms did not result from deliberate plans
    but emerged organically through four types of stakeholder-engaged initiatives,
    including customer-oriented service innovation, co-creative service delivery, inclusive
    decision-making, and relational business growth, presenting a shift of responsiveness
    towards openness. The sustain and institutionalization of these practices were
    underpinned by five key enabling mechanisms: (1) data-driven management
    mechanism, (2) paradoxical management balancing standardization with flexibility, (3)
    continuous employee development fostering habitus formation, (4) relational nurturing
    through long-term partnerships, and (5) contextualized technology empowerment. Over
    time, these adaptive processes yielded significant intended and unintended
    achievements, including enhanced operational efficiency and sustainable
    organizational learning and adaptability.

    The findings are synthesized into a three-layer framework that conceptualizes OS as a
    process of endogenous emergence rather than planned design, complementing existing
    OS models and proposing ‘dwelling mode of openness’. This framework contributes to
    theory by: contextualizing SAP and OS within a non-Western setting (China);
    challenging the design imperative in OS; identifying adaptive mechanisms that support
    unintended openness; and augmenting concepts like ‘practice drift.’ Practically, this
    study proposes a framework of emergent strategizing, providing an alternative roadmap
    for organizations, especially SMEs or traditional hierarchal organizations, to cultivate
    strategic openness by recognizing, nurturing, and scaffolding the latent potential
    inherent in their everyday adaptive actions.
    Date of AwardSept 2025
    Original languageEnglish
    Awarding Institution
    • Aston University
    SupervisorUwe Napiersky (Supervisor)

    Keywords

    • Open Strategy
    • Strategy-as-Practice
    • Emergent Strategy
    • Organic Openness
    • Practice Theory
    • China Context
    • Property Management
    • Qualitative Research

    Cite this

    '