Quantifying uncertainty in citizen weather data

  • Simon Bell

Student thesis: Doctoral ThesisDoctor of Philosophy

Abstract

The sheer volume of citizen weather data collected and uploaded to online data hubs is immense. However as with any citizen data it is difficult to assess the accuracy of the measurements. Within this project we quantify just how much data is available, where it comes from, the frequency at which it is collected, and the types of automatic weather stations being used. We also list the numerous possible sources of error and uncertainty within citizen weather observations before showing evidence of such effects in real data. A thorough intercomparison field study was conducted, testing popular models of citizen weather stations. From this study we were able to parameterise key sources of bias. Most significantly the project develops a complete quality control system through which citizen air temperature observations can be passed. The structure of this system was heavily informed by the results of the field study. Using a Bayesian framework the system learns and updates its estimates of the calibration and radiation-induced biases inherent to each station. We then show the benefit of correcting for these learnt biases over using the original uncorrected data. The system also attaches an uncertainty estimate to each observation, which would provide real world applications that choose to incorporate such observations with a measure on which they may base their confidence in the data. The system relies on interpolated temperature and radiation observations from neighbouring professional weather stations for which a Bayesian regression model is used. We recognise some of the assumptions and flaws of the developed system and suggest further work that needs to be done to bring it to an operational setting. Such a system will hopefully allow applications to leverage the additional value citizen weather data brings to longstanding professional observing networks.
Date of Award7 Jul 2015
LanguageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • Aston University
SupervisorDan Cornford (Supervisor), Lucy Bastin (Supervisor) & Mike Molyneux (Supervisor)

Keywords

  • amateur
  • bias
  • user-contributed
  • bayesian

Cite this

Quantifying uncertainty in citizen weather data
Bell, S. (Author). 7 Jul 2015

Student thesis: Doctoral ThesisDoctor of Philosophy