'Your situation is critical...': the discursive enactment of leadership by business women in Middle Eastern and Western European contexts

Judith Baxter, Haleema Al-A'ali

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Women remain in a small minority as business leaders in both Middle Eastern (ME) and Western European (WE) regions, and indeed, past research indicates that ME women face even greater challenges as leaders than their Western counterparts. This article explores sample findings from two separate case studies, the first of a ME woman leader and the second of a WE woman leader, each conducting a management meeting with their teams. Using interactional sociolinguistic analysis, we examine the 'contextualisation cues' that index how each woman performs leadership in their respective meetings. We found that both women utilise relational practices in order to enact leadership with their subordinates, but with varying results. Whereas the ME leader deploys a confident and commanding interactional style with her colleagues, the WE leader's style is evasive and uncertain. On the basis of these two cases, the WE leader appears to face greater challenges in a male-dominated business world than the ME leader. Whereas the ME leader can rely on long-established ties of loyalty and organisation-as-family, the Western leader, within an apparently more open, democratic context, has to negotiate overwhelming turbulence and change within her company. © 2014, equinox publishing.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)91-116
Number of pages25
JournalGender and Language
Volume8
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Dec 2014

Fingerprint

leadership
leader
Enactment
Discursive
sociolinguistics
loyalty
minority
management

Keywords

  • gender
  • language
  • leadership
  • relational practices

Cite this

@article{fc1c90cde65d44eb95220ed8287a0097,
title = "'Your situation is critical...': the discursive enactment of leadership by business women in Middle Eastern and Western European contexts",
abstract = "Women remain in a small minority as business leaders in both Middle Eastern (ME) and Western European (WE) regions, and indeed, past research indicates that ME women face even greater challenges as leaders than their Western counterparts. This article explores sample findings from two separate case studies, the first of a ME woman leader and the second of a WE woman leader, each conducting a management meeting with their teams. Using interactional sociolinguistic analysis, we examine the 'contextualisation cues' that index how each woman performs leadership in their respective meetings. We found that both women utilise relational practices in order to enact leadership with their subordinates, but with varying results. Whereas the ME leader deploys a confident and commanding interactional style with her colleagues, the WE leader's style is evasive and uncertain. On the basis of these two cases, the WE leader appears to face greater challenges in a male-dominated business world than the ME leader. Whereas the ME leader can rely on long-established ties of loyalty and organisation-as-family, the Western leader, within an apparently more open, democratic context, has to negotiate overwhelming turbulence and change within her company. {\circledC} 2014, equinox publishing.",
keywords = "gender, language, leadership , relational practices",
author = "Judith Baxter and Haleema Al-A'ali",
year = "2014",
month = "12",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1558/genl.v8i1.91",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "91--116",
journal = "Gender and Language",
issn = "1747-6321",
publisher = "Equinox Publishing Ltd",
number = "1",

}

'Your situation is critical...' : the discursive enactment of leadership by business women in Middle Eastern and Western European contexts. / Baxter, Judith; Al-A'ali, Haleema.

In: Gender and Language, Vol. 8, No. 1, 31.12.2014, p. 91-116.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'Your situation is critical...'

T2 - the discursive enactment of leadership by business women in Middle Eastern and Western European contexts

AU - Baxter, Judith

AU - Al-A'ali, Haleema

PY - 2014/12/31

Y1 - 2014/12/31

N2 - Women remain in a small minority as business leaders in both Middle Eastern (ME) and Western European (WE) regions, and indeed, past research indicates that ME women face even greater challenges as leaders than their Western counterparts. This article explores sample findings from two separate case studies, the first of a ME woman leader and the second of a WE woman leader, each conducting a management meeting with their teams. Using interactional sociolinguistic analysis, we examine the 'contextualisation cues' that index how each woman performs leadership in their respective meetings. We found that both women utilise relational practices in order to enact leadership with their subordinates, but with varying results. Whereas the ME leader deploys a confident and commanding interactional style with her colleagues, the WE leader's style is evasive and uncertain. On the basis of these two cases, the WE leader appears to face greater challenges in a male-dominated business world than the ME leader. Whereas the ME leader can rely on long-established ties of loyalty and organisation-as-family, the Western leader, within an apparently more open, democratic context, has to negotiate overwhelming turbulence and change within her company. © 2014, equinox publishing.

AB - Women remain in a small minority as business leaders in both Middle Eastern (ME) and Western European (WE) regions, and indeed, past research indicates that ME women face even greater challenges as leaders than their Western counterparts. This article explores sample findings from two separate case studies, the first of a ME woman leader and the second of a WE woman leader, each conducting a management meeting with their teams. Using interactional sociolinguistic analysis, we examine the 'contextualisation cues' that index how each woman performs leadership in their respective meetings. We found that both women utilise relational practices in order to enact leadership with their subordinates, but with varying results. Whereas the ME leader deploys a confident and commanding interactional style with her colleagues, the WE leader's style is evasive and uncertain. On the basis of these two cases, the WE leader appears to face greater challenges in a male-dominated business world than the ME leader. Whereas the ME leader can rely on long-established ties of loyalty and organisation-as-family, the Western leader, within an apparently more open, democratic context, has to negotiate overwhelming turbulence and change within her company. © 2014, equinox publishing.

KW - gender

KW - language

KW - leadership

KW - relational practices

UR - http://www.equinoxpub.com/journals/index.php/GL/article/view/16540

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84897139521&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1558/genl.v8i1.91

DO - 10.1558/genl.v8i1.91

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 91

EP - 116

JO - Gender and Language

JF - Gender and Language

SN - 1747-6321

IS - 1

ER -